Home of the Square Pizza
Since 1958

678 Stewart Avenue 
Garden City, NY 11530
(516) 228- 4300

  Home  |  Menu  |  Catering Order Online  | Coupons/Specials Contact Us  |  Directions       

Pizza Supreme (516) 228-4300

Home of the Square Pizza Since 1958 

We offer pizza, pasta, salads, specialties and more, serving our community for 57 years!

For the perfect gift, we have Gift Certificates available for the Pizza Supreme lover in your life.
We proudly serve home style Italian food and FREE local delivery.

 Don't forget, let us cater your next occasion!


Pizza Supreme - the taste that has been bringing Long Island back for over 50 years!

678 Stewart Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530

Contact Pizza Supreme!  (516) 228-4300